Saudi Press

Saudi Arabia and the world
Tuesday, Oct 22, 2024

Crypto trading should be treated like a type of gambling, influential MPs say

Crypto trading should be treated like a type of gambling, influential MPs say

The Treasury Committee made the recommendation while describing digital currencies as having "no intrinsic value and no useful social purpose".
An influential panel of MPs has called on the government to regulate consumer crypto trading and speculation as a type of gambling.

The cross-party Treasury Committee claimed digital currencies such as Bitcoin and Ether have "no intrinsic value and no useful social purpose" - and as well as consuming large amounts of energy, they are often used by criminals for scams.

It comes after the government announced proposals in February to regulate the crypto industry by bringing it under financial services law.

But MPs said a better approach would be to recognise how speculation in unbacked cryptoassets - like Bitcoin - "more closely resembles gambling than a financial service".

It recommended that safeguarding rules which oversee the likes of lotteries, betting firms and casinos should apply instead.

Around 10% of UK adults have speculated in cryptoassets, according to HM Revenue and Customs.

The committee's new report warned digital currencies are a "significant risk" due to "huge" price volatility, with the potential for customers to lose everything they invest.

It said there was evidence that addictions to cryptocurrency speculation were on the rise - and warned there are limited controls currently in place to protect vulnerable consumers.

MPs said they were concerned that bringing the industry under financial service regulation "will create a 'halo' effect that leads consumers to believe that this activity is safer than it is, or protected when it is not".

"We therefore strongly recommend that the government regulates retail trading and investment activity in unbacked cryptoassets as gambling rather than as a financial service, consistent with its stated principle of 'same risk, same regulatory outcome,'" the report added.

A 'Wild West' industry

It comes after a 2018 report by the committee described the cryptocurrency industry as a "Wild West" - with MPs saying nothing in their subsequent enquiries had moved them to alter that verdict.

Following the new report, committee chair, Conservative MP Harriett Baldwin, said: "Effective regulation is clearly needed to protect consumers from harm, as well as to support productive innovation in the UK's financial services industry.

"However, with no intrinsic value, huge price volatility and no discernible social good, consumer trading of cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin more closely resembles gambling than a financial service, and should be regulated as such."

The MPs said they still felt there was potential in the technology - such as by improving the efficiency and costs of making payments - and advised the government to take a "balanced approach" in supporting innovation.

The committee added it was separately considering the potential role of digital currencies backed by central banks.

Meanwhile its report also criticised the government's attempt in April 2022 to launch a non-fungible token (NFT) - a type of cryptocurrency asset - through the Royal Mint. The plan was dropped earlier this year following a review.

MPs said the government "should seek to avoid expending public resources on supporting cryptoasset activities without a clear, beneficial use case".

Crypto 'offers opportunities'

It comes as the government considers responses to a consultation into its regulation proposals.

A Treasury spokesperson indicated ministers would likely reject the committee's recommendation.

They told Sky News: "Risks posed by crypto are typical of those that exist in traditional financial services and it's financial services regulation - rather than gambling regulation - that has the track record in mitigating them.

"Crypto offers opportunities but we are taking an agile approach to robustly regulating the market, addressing the most pressing risks first in a way that promotes innovation."

The report comes amid growing pressure on governments around the world to better regulate the industry, heightened by the sudden bankruptcy of crypto platform FTX in November.

Some 80,000 UK-based customers were impacted by the collapse, and one British investor was left with a £1m hole in his finances.

The European Union this week approved tougher cryptoasset rules - including new powers to ban exchanges that fail to protect consumers.

The International Organisation of Securities Commissions (IOSCO), whose members include regulators in the US and UK, said it will also soon announce proposals for the first ever set of global rules covering crypto trading.
Newsletter

Related Articles

Saudi Press
0:00
0:00
Close
Egypt Shifts Energy Goals Amid Gas Challenges; Saudi Arabia Celebrates Military and Culinary Achievements; Moldovans Vote on EU Alignment
Israeli Airstrike Targets Hezbollah's Financial Resources
Farewell to Liam Payne: A Tribute Amidst Saudi Arabia's Transformative Cultural and Technological Advancements
Heartwarming Rescue: Saudi Stray Cats and Dogs Find New Homes in the Philippines Through Global Efforts
Saudi Aid Lands in Beirut, Saudi Culture Celebrated in Mauritania, and Global Reactions to Middle East Tensions
Global Challenges and Triumphs: From Middle East Peace Calls to Historic Sports Achievements
Global Tensions and Diplomatic Moves: From King Charles's Australian Tour to Rising Middle Eastern Conflicts
Global Tensions Rise: Harris Challenges Trump in Michigan, Humanitarian Efforts Expand, and Middle East Conflicts Escalate
Escalating Middle East Tensions Highlight Multifaceted Security Challenges and Political Maneuvering on Global Stage
Global Tensions and Local Debates: Key Highlights from Monarchical Visits to Criminal Justice Reforms
From Art Tributes to Legal Disputes: Global Interconnections in Justice and Humanitarian Efforts
Saudi Arabia's Global and Domestic Initiatives: From Humanitarian Aid to Economic Growth and Disaster Preparedness
Tragic Loss, Diplomatic Moves, and Global Struggles: Key Stories Shaping Our World Today
Global Tensions and Crises: Humanitarian Challenges in Gaza, Rising Gang Violence in Sweden, and Political Complexities in South Asia
EU Frustration, Saudi Growth, and Green Initiatives: A Global Snapshot of Economic and Cultural Developments
French Cement Giant Lafarge Faces Trial for Terror Financing; Global Stories Unfold: Fake Bomb Threats in India, Egypt-Iran Diplomacy, and Student Debt Relief in the US
Hong Kong's Rare Conviction of Policemen, Rising Oil Prices, and Global Geopolitical Tensions: A Worldwide Snapshot
Global Tensions and Humanitarian Crises: U.S.-Israel Talks, Ukraine Conflict, and India-Canada Diplomatic Strain
Xi Jinping Urges Troops to Prepare for Conflict Amid Taiwan Drills
Netanyahu Condemns Alleged Hezbollah Assassination Attempt
Israeli Leaflet Campaign in Gaza: A Critical Update
Saudi Arabia Launches Global Harmony Initiative Amid Escalating Middle East Tensions
Surge in Bomb Threat Hoaxes Strikes Indian Airlines Amidst Weather Chaos and Global Economic Shifts
Global Turmoil: Hoax Bomb Threats Disrupt Indian Flights, Russian Sailor's Survival Story, and Calls for Clemency Shake U.S. Justice
Global Shifts: Sudan's Crisis, Middle East Tensions, and the Push Towards Green Energy
Elon Musk's $75 Million Donation Boosts Pro-Trump Efforts Amid Global Political Shifts
Global Shifts: China-U.S. Diplomacy, Korean Tensions, Middle Eastern Peace Calls, EU Initiatives, and Indonesia’s Halal Compliance
Hamas Chief Yahya Sinwar Killed in Israeli Operation
Biden Praises Israel's Military Action Against Hamas Chief Yahya Sinwar
Yahya Sinwar’s Death Marks Pivotal Moment in Gaza War
Global Tensions Surge: Hate Crime in Maryland, Rising Middle Eastern Conflicts, and US Political Drama Unfold
Hezbollah Deputy Chief Calls for Ceasefire Amidst Escalating Conflict with Israel
US Warns Israel of Potential Aid Cuts Over Gaza Assistance Delays
Global Solar Initiatives Surge in Saudi Arabia Amidst Rising Middle East Tensions
Israeli Airstrike in Lebanon Sparks UN Investigation Calls Amid Rising Regional Tensions and Global Responses
Saudi Arabia Champions Cultural and Diplomatic Initiatives for Middle East Stability and Palestinian Support
Turkiye Protests Intensify Amid Rising Femicides as Global Tensions Escalate and EU-GCC Summit Approaches
Saudi Arabia’s Shoura Council Pushes for Educational Investment, as Global Relations and Cultural Contributions Shine
Lebanon's Healthcare Crisis Amid Conflict, Saudi Arabia's Green Campaign, and Sports Highlights: A Snapshot of Regional Developments
Global Developments: Pakistan's Lockdown for SCO Summit, EU Migration Challenges, US Voting Rights Legal Battles, and Boost in Saudi Markets
Sustainable Innovation: Riyadh's New Murabba Hits Milestone Amid Regional Security and Climate Initiatives
Remarkable Survival Tale and Global Economic Collaborations: From Russia to Saudi Arabia's Expanding Influence
From Saudi Art at G20 to Lebanon's Rising Tensions: Navigating Global Cultural and Political Currents
Kamala Harris Courts Black and Latino Voters; UN Condemns Israeli Attacks; Saudi Arabia Launches International Qur’an Competition; Study of Al-Wahbah Crater Unveils Potential Extraterrestrial Insights; Pioneering Robotic Organ Transplants in Riyadh; Saudi Crown Prince’s Diplomatic Visit to Egypt
Egypt Reduces External Debt by $15 Billion as Islamic Development Bank Commits $3 Billion to Global Projects; Middle East Tensions Highlighted by Recent Developments
Global Developments: Italian Troops' Safety, Afghan Relocations, and Political Shifts in Indonesia
Global Economic Turbulence: IMF Debt Warning, Oil Price Slump, and Sustainability Initiatives
Escalating Tensions in Gaza and Beyond: Regional Leaders Respond Amidst Global Unrest
Rising Tensions: Israel Strikes Lebanon, Iran Denies Missile Transfers, and China Conducts Drills Near Taiwan
Arab American PAC Breaks Tradition, Global Tensions Rise, and New Alliances Form
×