Saudi Press

Saudi Arabia and the world
Saturday, Feb 22, 2025

As Clubhouse's popularity skyrockets, some observers are raising questions about the spread of misinformation

As Clubhouse's popularity skyrockets, some observers are raising questions about the spread of misinformation

As Clubhouse downloads doubled last month, tech experts started to voice concerns about how the audio app will be able to moderate content.

In a recent Clubhouse discussion about COVID-19 vaccines, a woman digitally raised her hand, entered the conversation, and spoke at length about how the virus could be treated more effectively with herbal and natural remedies than with vaccines.

She told dozens of listeners: "A pharmaceutical company is an industry, a business, just like anything else and everyone else, who is devoted specifically and exclusively to making sure their shareholders have profits, quarter over quarter. It is not about your health. It is not about your wellness."

Clubhouse, which launched as an invite-only app last March, has in recent weeks surged in popularity to become one of the world's most-downloaded iPhone apps. As of March 1, it had been downloaded about 11.4 million times, according to App Annie, a mobile data tracker. That was up from just 3.5 million a month earlier.

The company said in late February that it had more than 10 million active users each week.

As its growth skyrocketed this year, some technologists and academics began asking questions about how it moderates conversations. Outsiders were wondering about bots and the spread of misinformation — the same types of questions that have long been asked about Facebook, Twitter, and other social networks.

While vaccine discussions on Clubhouse may simply go against company guidelines — along with those from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention — other conversations were more incendiary.

In one high-profile instance, a Twitter user shared a screenshot of a Clubhouse room called: "Were 6 million Jews really killed?"After users reported that room, the company said on Twitter: "This has no place on Clubhouse. Actions have been taken. We unequivocally condemn Anti-Semitism and all other forms of racism and hate speech."

But some observers questioned whether less inflammatory misinformation had slipped through the cracks.

"Thus far, the creators of the app have been less concerned with misinformation, and more so with the growing number of users on the platform," said Heinrich Long, a privacy expert at Restore Privacy.

By design, Clubhouse encourages users to explore, and jump in and out of discussions. At any given moment, there are hundreds or thousands of conversations in many different languages, making moderation a daunting task.

The company's been building a Trust & Safety team for the last year, growing its numbers alongside the platform. As of Saturday, it had two public job postings for that team on its website.

Clubhouse declined an interview request for this story, but a spokesperson sent a statement saying "racism, hate speech and abuse are prohibited on Clubhouse." Such speech would violate the company's guidelines and terms.

"The spreading or sharing of misinformation is strictly prohibited on Clubhouse. Clubhouse strongly encourages people to report any violations of our Terms of Service or Community Guidelines," the spokesperson said via email.

They added: "If it is determined that a violation has taken place, Clubhouse may warn, suspend, or remove the user from the platform, based on the severity of the violation."

Everything said on Clubhouse is recorded in the moment, according to the app's guidelines. While discussions are live, the company keeps that encrypted recording. But after a conversation ends, the recording is destroyed. The only time where a conversation would be saved longer was when a listener flagged it to the company.

That moderation model is similar to the one used by Reddit, which largely relies on crowdsourced moderation, said Paul Bischoff, a privacy advocate at Comparitech. Unlike text-based Reddit, however, there won't be a permanent record of every audio interaction on Clubhouse.

"That could lead to insulated echo chambers where misinformation is amplified without any outside viewpoints," Bischoff said. "The live-ness could prevent people from being able to report bad behavior on the app, but it could also stem the spread of misinformation beyond the app."

In the conversation about vaccines, for example, one user asked the woman touting herbal COVID-19 remedies if she could share her information, so listeners could reach out offline to learn more about why vaccines weren't the best solution for the coronavirus.

There's also a question of how bots or large groups of coordinated users could affect conversations on the app, said Sam Crowther, founder and chief executive at Kasada, a company that identifies bot activity.

Crowther said he's already seen some chatter on bot-related message boards about how Clubhouse could be exploited.

"One of the underlying truths with internet businesses is that if you build it, they'll make a bot to exploit it," Crowther said, adding, "Removing fake accounts after they're live is too late — companies need to take control and seize bad bots at registration."

The app encourages users to explore, and jump in and out of discussions.


So how can Clubhouse effectively moderate thousands of conversations between millions of users, many of whom are speaking local languages?

Like Facebook and other social networks, Clubhouse would do best with some form of artificial intelligence or voice pattern recognition system, said Stephen Hunnewell, executive director at the ADALA Project, a nonprofit that advocates for free speech around the world.

But, Hunnewell said, the real danger of audio conversations is that the content can't be unheard.

Take the conversation about curing COVID-19 with herbal remedies. Dozens of people listening to that conversation already digested the information. Even if the conversation was flagged in real time, Clubhouse couldn't guarantee that false information wasn't spread further by those who had already heard it.

"The real danger is in the cross-pollination that seed has planted within whatever audience heard it and their further amplification," Hunnewell said.

With a new platform like Clubhouse, which has scaled to millions of users in a short space of time, every new user counts, said Nir Kshetri, a professor at the University of North Carolina-Greensboro. That's why a young company like Clubhouse could choose to prioritize growth at all costs.

Kshetri compared Clubhouse to bigger competitors, like Microsoft, which runs LinkedIn. That company's been around for decades, and employs some 3,500 experts focused on cybercrime, artificial intelligence, and machine learning, he said.

For a small company like Clubhouse, it may take years to build similarly robust misinformation-tracking systems. In the end, it's more a decision for the management, he added.

"The question of whether social network sites should play the role of gatekeeper for the news and information their users consume is more philosophical than technological," Kshetri said.

Even now, some users are fighting back against what they see as misinformation on Clubhouse. In the chat about vaccines, where a woman spoke in favor of herbal remedies for COVID-19, a doctor was responding in real time to claims made in the room. A few times during the hourslong conversation, he popped in to express his opinions.

"I agree with some of what you're saying, but I don't agree with all of it," he said, before finally exiting the room.

Newsletter

Related Articles

Saudi Press
0:00
0:00
Close
Saudi Arabia and the United States Strengthen Ties Amid Global Developments
Saudi Arabia Hosts Global Conference to Promote Islamic Unity
The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on Education and Child Development
Saudi Arabia Announces Competition for Best Founding Day Outfits
Saudi-EU Food Security Officials Hold Talks to Strengthen Collaboration
Putin Expresses Gratitude to Saudi Crown Prince for Hosting US-Russia Talks
UK and Saudi Arabia Enhance Collaboration in Innovation and Technology
Denmark's Embassy in Riyadh Showcases Danish Cuisine with Saudi Influence
Saudi Artist Salman Al-Amir Unveils 'Tafawut' Exhibition in Riyadh
Saudi Arabia Offers Condolences to Kuwait Following Military Exercise Fatalities
Saudi Ministry of Islamic Affairs Completes Ramadan Preparations in Madinah
Etidal Secretary-General Hosts UN Counter-Terrorism Director in Riyadh
ADNOC Drilling Targets Over $1 Billion in Investments for 2025 Amid Gulf Expansion Plans
Derayah Financial Achieves Remarkable Growth in Saudi Brokerage and Asset Management
Saudi Arabia Shortlists 30 Firms for Mining Licenses in Eastern Province and Tabuk
Saudi Foreign Minister Engages Counterparts at G20 Meeting in Johannesburg
Oil Prices Decline Amid Rising US Inventories
Saudi Arabia's NDMC Plans Green Bond Issuance by 2025
Moody’s Affirms Egypt’s Caa1 Rating Amid Positive Economic Outlook
Oman and Saudi Arabia Strengthen Economic Ties with New Agreements
Saudi Arabia Investments Propel Expansion of Qurayyah Power Plant
Saudi Capital Market Authority Advances SPACs and Direct Listings
Global Energy Leaders Gather in Riyadh for Symposium on Energy Outlooks
Al-Ahsa Region Sees 500% Growth in Tourism as Saudi Arabia Prioritizes Development
Saudi Arabia Advances Entrepreneurial Ecosystem in Al-Ahsa with New Agreement
King Salman Approves Official Saudi Riyal Symbol
Saudi Credit Card Lending Reaches $8.4 Billion Amid Digital Payment Expansion
King Salman Approves Official Symbol for Saudi Riyal
Putin Thanks Saudi Crown Prince for Facilitating U.S.-Russia Discussions
Saudi Foreign Minister Attends G20 Meeting in Johannesburg
Saudi Arabia Prepares for Nationwide Founding Day Celebrations
Inauguration of Hira Park and Walkway Enhances Jeddah's Urban Landscape
Crown Prince Hosts Leaders for Informal Meeting in Riyadh Amid Gaza Rebuilding Plans
Saudi Official Highlights Achievements and Media's Role in National Transformation
Three Expatriate Women Arrested for Prostitution in Riyadh
Saudi Arabia's Diplomatic Evolution Highlighted at Saudi Media Forum
Healthy Eating and Preparation Essential for Ramadan Fasting
Saudi Arabia and Japan Forge Sustainable Textile Partnership
Advanced Limb Surgery Restores Mobility in Pediatric Cancer Patient
Jeddah Event Explores AI's Role in Boosting Saudi Arabia's SME Sector
UN Representative Highlights AI's Role in Perpetuating Gender Stereotypes
Saudi and Jordanian Leaders Discuss Enhanced Security Cooperation in Amman
Saudi British Society Honors Cultural Bridge-Builders at London Gala
Saudi Media Forum 2025 Explores AI's Role in Modern Journalism
Saudi Arabia's Saqer Al-Moqbel Appointed as WTO General Council President for 2025–2026
Saudi Deputy Ministers Engage in Diplomatic Discussions with U.S. and Dutch Officials in Riyadh
Saudi Arabia to Launch Iftar Program in 61 Countries During Ramadan
Saudi Visitors Expected to Spend £942 Million in UK During 2025
Saudi Arabia Gifts Kaaba's Kiswah to Uzbekistan's Center of Islamic Civilization
Digital Cooperation Organization Concludes Fourth General Assembly with Multiple Agreements
×