Saudi Press

Saudi Arabia and the world
Sunday, Dec 01, 2024

Can Donald Trump Bring Peace to the Middle East—or Is It Beyond His Reach?

Donald Trump is back, promising to take on the world's most intractable conflicts with his characteristic bravado. Among his boldest claims: resolving the Middle East’s long-standing turmoil. In his signature style, the former president has pledged to "finish Israel’s Gaza and Lebanon operations quickly" and even claims he could resolve the Ukraine war in just 24 hours. But as Trump prepares to step back onto the global stage, the question remains: can his deal-making prowess succeed where decades of diplomacy have failed?
The Middle East is a region riddled with historic grievances, shifting alliances, and mounting tensions. With Israel entangled in conflicts on multiple fronts—Gaza, Lebanon, and direct skirmishes with Iran—Trump faces a task that has humbled his predecessors. Yet his supporters argue that his first term laid the groundwork for peace through the groundbreaking Abraham Accords.


Trump’s Legacy: The Abraham Accords

It’s impossible to discuss Trump’s Middle East credentials without acknowledging the Abraham Accords. Brokered during his first term, these agreements normalized relations between Israel and several Arab states, including the UAE and Bahrain. Critics dismissed Trump’s unorthodox diplomacy, but the accords represented a rare glimmer of progress in a region often defined by stalemate.

Unlike Biden, who has pursued a more conventional and often reactive approach, Trump has consistently positioned himself as a disruptor. His recognition of Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and the relocation of the U.S. embassy drew widespread condemnation but solidified his reputation as a staunch ally of Israel. His supporters argue that these bold moves strengthened U.S.-Israel ties while setting the stage for broader regional cooperation.


The Challenges Ahead

However, Trump’s second act won’t be as straightforward. The dynamics in the Middle East have shifted dramatically since his departure from office. Saudi Arabia, a key U.S. ally, has strengthened ties with its once-archrival Iran, a move that would have been unthinkable just a few years ago. Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman has made the establishment of a Palestinian state a prerequisite for further normalization with Israel—a condition that complicates Trump’s “Israel first” approach.

At the same time, the humanitarian crises in Gaza and southern Lebanon have escalated, fueling public outrage across the Arab world. This anger puts leaders like MBS in a precarious position, balancing their own pragmatic interests with rising pressure from their populations.

Meanwhile, Iran, emboldened by its alliances with Russia and China, is far less vulnerable to U.S. sanctions than it was during Trump’s first term. The “maximum pressure” campaign that Trump implemented to curb Tehran’s ambitions may no longer yield the same results, especially as global energy dynamics have shifted.


Biden’s Escalation vs. Trump’s Restraint

Trump’s critics often deride his impulsiveness, but his record shows a surprising level of restraint in military affairs. Unlike Joe Biden, whose administration has supported prolonged military engagements in Ukraine and elsewhere, Trump did not initiate any new wars during his presidency. His foreign policy was transactional, focused on securing U.S. interests rather than fueling the military-industrial complex.

Biden’s approach, in contrast, has been criticized for escalating conflicts without clear endgames. The prolonged war in Ukraine, the intensification of tensions with China, and a lack of decisive action in the Middle East have led to questions about Washington’s priorities. Critics argue that Biden’s policies enrich defense contractors while doing little to resolve the root causes of these conflicts.

This distinction is central to Trump’s appeal as a peace negotiator. By prioritizing deals over drawn-out military campaigns, Trump could position himself as a leader focused on tangible outcomes rather than perpetual conflict.


A High-Stakes Balancing Act

Yet Trump’s unwavering support for Israel could also become his Achilles’ heel. While his actions have earned him plaudits in Tel Aviv, they risk alienating key Arab allies. Saudi Arabia’s insistence on a Palestinian state underscores the delicate balancing act Trump must perform to maintain regional stability.

Furthermore, Netanyahu’s aggressive policies in Gaza and the West Bank complicate Trump’s path forward. The Israeli prime minister’s hardline stance and domestic challenges make him an unpredictable ally. Trump’s ability to navigate these complexities will be critical in determining whether his Middle East strategy succeeds or falters.


The Verdict

Donald Trump’s return to the global stage comes at a time of heightened volatility in the Middle East. His track record suggests he is uniquely equipped to shake up the status quo, but the challenges he faces are formidable. From Iran’s growing influence to the shifting priorities of Arab states, the path to peace is fraught with obstacles.

Supporters of Trump argue that his transactional approach and disdain for endless wars make him the ideal candidate to broker peace. Critics, however, warn that his bold moves could exacerbate tensions and undermine U.S. credibility in the region.

As Trump prepares to reenter the fray, one thing is certain: the world will be watching. Whether he cements his legacy as a peacemaker or a polarizer remains to be seen. For now, the Middle East remains as unpredictable as ever—its future shaped by leaders, grievances, and a region that defies easy solutions.
Newsletter

Related Articles

Saudi Press
0:00
0:00
Close
Israel Offers $5 Million for Each Gaza Hostage Freed
CIA Official Arrested for Leaking Intelligence on Israel-Iran Conflict
A Chinese retail chain has swapped out traditional mannequins for real women walking on treadmills, displaying their clothing in action.
Iranian Man Charged in Plot to Assassinate Donald Trump
IMF Projects Economic Growth for Middle East as Saudi Arabia Emerges as a Tech and Investment Powerhouse
Saudi Arabia Commits $25 Billion to Strengthen Economic Ties with Africa Amid Vision 2030 Goals
Saudi Arabia Crown Prince, Mohammed Bin Salman calls for Netanyahu to be held criminally responsible for crimes against Palestinians
Escalating Conflicts, Legal Battles, and Global Alliances: A Snapshot of Today's International Headlines
Saudi Arabia's Vision 2030: Advancing Tourism, Sports, and AI in Urban Transformation
Middle East in Turmoil: Yemen's Outcry Over Custody Death, Hezbollah Leadership Hit, and Saudi Arabia's Bold Economic Moves
Madinah's Tourism Boom: A 124% Surge as UN Tensions Escalate and Saudi Arabia Expands Opportunities for Women
Blinken Sees Opportunity in Hamas Leader's Death
Israel Eliminates Successor of Hezbollah Leader Hassan Nasrallah
Egypt Shifts Energy Goals Amid Gas Challenges; Saudi Arabia Celebrates Military and Culinary Achievements; Moldovans Vote on EU Alignment
Israeli Airstrike Targets Hezbollah's Financial Resources
Farewell to Liam Payne: A Tribute Amidst Saudi Arabia's Transformative Cultural and Technological Advancements
Heartwarming Rescue: Saudi Stray Cats and Dogs Find New Homes in the Philippines Through Global Efforts
Saudi Aid Lands in Beirut, Saudi Culture Celebrated in Mauritania, and Global Reactions to Middle East Tensions
Global Challenges and Triumphs: From Middle East Peace Calls to Historic Sports Achievements
Global Tensions and Diplomatic Moves: From King Charles's Australian Tour to Rising Middle Eastern Conflicts
Global Tensions Rise: Harris Challenges Trump in Michigan, Humanitarian Efforts Expand, and Middle East Conflicts Escalate
Escalating Middle East Tensions Highlight Multifaceted Security Challenges and Political Maneuvering on Global Stage
Global Tensions and Local Debates: Key Highlights from Monarchical Visits to Criminal Justice Reforms
From Art Tributes to Legal Disputes: Global Interconnections in Justice and Humanitarian Efforts
Saudi Arabia's Global and Domestic Initiatives: From Humanitarian Aid to Economic Growth and Disaster Preparedness
Tragic Loss, Diplomatic Moves, and Global Struggles: Key Stories Shaping Our World Today
Global Tensions and Crises: Humanitarian Challenges in Gaza, Rising Gang Violence in Sweden, and Political Complexities in South Asia
EU Frustration, Saudi Growth, and Green Initiatives: A Global Snapshot of Economic and Cultural Developments
French Cement Giant Lafarge Faces Trial for Terror Financing; Global Stories Unfold: Fake Bomb Threats in India, Egypt-Iran Diplomacy, and Student Debt Relief in the US
Hong Kong's Rare Conviction of Policemen, Rising Oil Prices, and Global Geopolitical Tensions: A Worldwide Snapshot
Global Tensions and Humanitarian Crises: U.S.-Israel Talks, Ukraine Conflict, and India-Canada Diplomatic Strain
Xi Jinping Urges Troops to Prepare for Conflict Amid Taiwan Drills
Netanyahu Condemns Alleged Hezbollah Assassination Attempt
Israeli Leaflet Campaign in Gaza: A Critical Update
Saudi Arabia Launches Global Harmony Initiative Amid Escalating Middle East Tensions
Surge in Bomb Threat Hoaxes Strikes Indian Airlines Amidst Weather Chaos and Global Economic Shifts
Global Turmoil: Hoax Bomb Threats Disrupt Indian Flights, Russian Sailor's Survival Story, and Calls for Clemency Shake U.S. Justice
Global Shifts: Sudan's Crisis, Middle East Tensions, and the Push Towards Green Energy
Elon Musk's $75 Million Donation Boosts Pro-Trump Efforts Amid Global Political Shifts
Global Shifts: China-U.S. Diplomacy, Korean Tensions, Middle Eastern Peace Calls, EU Initiatives, and Indonesia’s Halal Compliance
Hamas Chief Yahya Sinwar Killed in Israeli Operation
Biden Praises Israel's Military Action Against Hamas Chief Yahya Sinwar
Yahya Sinwar’s Death Marks Pivotal Moment in Gaza War
Global Tensions Surge: Hate Crime in Maryland, Rising Middle Eastern Conflicts, and US Political Drama Unfold
Hezbollah Deputy Chief Calls for Ceasefire Amidst Escalating Conflict with Israel
US Warns Israel of Potential Aid Cuts Over Gaza Assistance Delays
Global Solar Initiatives Surge in Saudi Arabia Amidst Rising Middle East Tensions
Israeli Airstrike in Lebanon Sparks UN Investigation Calls Amid Rising Regional Tensions and Global Responses
Saudi Arabia Champions Cultural and Diplomatic Initiatives for Middle East Stability and Palestinian Support
Turkiye Protests Intensify Amid Rising Femicides as Global Tensions Escalate and EU-GCC Summit Approaches
×