Saudi Press

Saudi Arabia and the world
Sunday, Oct 13, 2024

WHO warns against long-term health risks of artificial sweeteners

WHO warns against long-term health risks of artificial sweeteners

Artificial sweeteners won’t help with weight loss and may raise the risk of diabetes, heart disease and death, says the World Health Organization (WHO).

Sugar substitutes such as stevia, aspartame and sucralose do not help people lose weight in the long run and may instead pose health risks, the World Health Organization has warned.

A systematic review of the available evidence "suggests that use of NSS [non-sugar sweeteners] does not confer any long-term benefit in reducing body fat in adults or children,” the WHO said in a statement.

“Results of the review also suggest that there may be potential undesirable effects from long-term use of NSS, such as an increased risk of type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular diseases, and mortality in adults,” it added.

Francesco Branca, WHO director for nutrition and food safety, said replacing sugars with artificial sweeteners "does not help with weight control in the long term,” and instead, “people need to consider other ways to reduce free sugars intakes, such as consuming food with naturally occurring sugars, like fruit, or unsweetened food and beverages”.

Artificial sweeteners are “not essential dietary factors and have no nutritional value,” Branca emphasised.

“People should reduce the sweetness of the diet altogether, starting early in life, to improve their health”.

Last year, a large study in France flagged a possible link between artificial sweeteners and an increased risk of cancer. And national health organisations such as Canada’s have long warned that zero-calorie or low-calorie sugar substitutes are neither necessary nor helpful.


Aspartame, stevia, sucralose all targeted


“Sugar substitutes do not need to be consumed to reduce the intake of free sugars,” the guidelines say, adding that, because “there are no well-established health benefits associated with the intake of sweeteners, nutritious foods and beverages that are unsweetened should be promoted instead”.

The WHO discourages the consumption of “all synthetic and naturally occurring or modified non-nutritive sweeteners that are not classified as sugars found in manufactured foods and beverages, or sold on their own to be added to foods and beverages by consumers”.

That includes acesulfame K, aspartame, advantame, cyclamates, neotame, saccharin, sucralose, stevia and stevia derivatives.

The recommendations do not apply to personal care and hygiene products containing NSS, such as toothpaste, skin cream, and medications, or to low-calorie sugars and sugar alcohols (polyols). These sugars or sugar derivatives do contain calories - they are therefore not considered sugar substitutes - and are commonly present in various food products such as sugar-free chewing gum and sugar-free candy.


New guidance sparks criticism


WHO’s new guidance applies to all people except those with pre-existing diabetes.

However, WHO emphasised it had been assessed “as conditional” due to the diversity of participants in the studies that formed the basis for its conclusions, as well as the very complex consumption habits of sugar-free sweeteners.

Some nutrition experts have quickly jumped in to point these out, saying the new guidelines were largely based on observational studies that do not establish a direct link between sweeteners and weight control.

First of all, it is important to understand the WHO’s advice “is to governments and policymakers, not to individuals,” said Tom Sanders, a professor emeritus of nutrition and dietetics at King's College London.

However, because of the way they have been presented, people are taking these recommendations as direct advice, he told Euronews Next, adding he expects them to create “a lot of confusion amongst consumers”.

“On one hand, they are being told by government, ‘avoid sugar-sweetened beverages,’ and on the other, ’well, actually you shouldn't be drinking artificial sweeteners’”.

The WHO’s review “does not really show any definite adverse effects, and they do sort of miss out on quite an important one, which is dental caries in children,” Sanders added, noting there is “clear evidence” that replacing sugar sweeteners does help with dental care.

Sanders criticised the guidance for not taking into account “the real-world situation,” particularly in the field of dietetics.

“Sometimes what you're trying to do is get people to control their weight, which is to reduce their calorie intake, and it can help if people are drinking a full sugary drink to switch to a reduced-calorie drink or zero-calorie drink,” he explained.

Indeed, artificial sweeteners have no nutritional value, but a lot of other things in our diet, like tea or coffee, also don’t, he said, “but, you know, people drink them rather than just drink water because they like the taste of it”.

Newsletter

Related Articles

Saudi Press
0:00
0:00
Close
Tesla's Robotaxi Design Strikes Controversy
Global Condemnation, Political Shifts, and Cultural Changes: Key Developments Around the World
Russia and Iran Bolster Economic Ties with Strategic Partnership Talks
Israel Issues Warning to Southern Lebanon Amid Ongoing Conflict
Poll Shows Trump Favored Over Harris in Handling Wars
Iran Enforces Electronics Ban on Flights After Lebanon Attacks
Gunfire Targets Jewish School in Toronto as Anti-Semitic Incidents Surge Across Canada
Global Tensions and Diplomatic Efforts: Key Developments from Turkey-Greece Talks to Electoral Concerns in Mozambique
Saudi Arabia Hosts Regional Environmental Summit Amid Rising Middle East Tensions
Saudi Arabia's Bold Reforms: Tax Exemptions, Water Security Initiatives, and Global Health Leadership Amid Middle East Tensions
100 Days of Keir Starmer: Navigating Economy, Controversies, and Global Challenges
Global Tensions Rise: Ukrainian Conscription Raids, Sectarian Clashes in Pakistan, and Natural Disasters in Florida and Nepal
Iranian Speaker Condemns Israeli Airstrike Amidst Regional Tensions; Saudi Arabia and Morocco Navigate Diplomatic Challenges
From Falconry to Foreign Relations: Exploring Heritage and Headlines Across the Middle East
Escalating Conflicts in Gaza and Lebanon Highlight Global Tensions Amid Nobel Peace Prize Reminders
Global Shifts: Navalny's Legacy, China's Taiwan Pressure, Saudi Arabia's Fintech Boom, and Middle East Tensions
Nicaragua Cuts Ties with Israel Amid Rising Global Tensions and Domestic Political Shifts
Putin and Pezeshkian Forge Economic Ties as Geopolitical Tensions Rise Across Middle East
Saudi Arabia Pursues Sustainable Future Amid Middle East Tensions and Iraq's Cultural Revival
Global Leaders Address Middle East Tensions Amid Regional Security Initiatives and Cultural Innovations
Bridging Cultures and Innovations: From Arabic Sign Language Tech to Saudi Heritage and Global Exhibitions
Cybersecurity Breach at Intesa Sanpaolo and Global Scandals: A Rundown of Key Developments
Noor Riyadh Celebrates Light Art Festival Amidst Middle East Tensions and Global Diplomatic Moves
Saudi Arabia Strengthens Global Economic Ties: Key Agreements and Strategic Investments Highlighted at Forums
Somalia Welcomes Egyptian Peacekeepers Amid Global Geopolitical Shifts and Economic Initiatives
Nobel Peace Prize 2024 Celebrates Japanese Atomic Bomb Survivors' Quest for a Nuclear-Free World
Global Tensions Rise: Spain Halts Arms Sales to Israel Amid Condemnation, While Middle East Conflicts Escalate
Global Alliances and Regional Tensions: A Week of Diplomatic Moves and Digital Advances
Global Challenges: UNHCR's Statelessness Victory, Hurricane Milton's Aftermath, and Rising Geopolitical Tensions
Historic Floods Reshape Sahara Desert Landscape
US Seeks Diplomatic Resolution in Lebanon Amid Rising Tensions
Ireland Urges Israel to Cease Fire on UN Peacekeepers in Lebanon
Global Tensions Unfold: ASEAN Summit Criticizes China's Actions, Middle East Violence Escalates, and Ukraine Seeks Ally Support
Global Unrest: Mining Tragedy in Balochistan, Israel-Palestine Tensions, and Exploitation in Russia Contrast Tesla's Tech Innovations
Global Tensions Rise: Germany's Arms to Israel, Turkey's Influence in Albania, and Crises in Gaza and South Sudan
Saudi Arabia Unveils New Tourism Codes Amid Regional Diplomatic and Humanitarian Developments
Saudi Arabia's Dynamic Week: Market Gains, Innovative Initiatives, and Community Development
EU and GCC Summit Aims to Alleviate Arab Conflicts and Boost €170 Billion Trade Partnership Amidst Global Turmoil
Saudi Arabia and Oman Forge Green Economy Pact Amidst Cultural and Technological Advances
Gaza Tragedy Sparks Outrage as Saudi Arabia and France Strengthen Defense Ties Amid Regional Conflicts
Oman's Economic Resilience Amid Regional Tensions: S&P Upgrades Credit Rating; Saudi Arabia Advances Social and Industrial Growth
KAUST to Host Prestigious World Academic Summit Amidst Global Unrest and Escalating Conflicts
Turkish Energy Bourse Eyes Carbon Markets and IPO Amid Global Chaos: Geopolitical Tensions, Natural Disasters, and Notable Losses
Global Leaders Address Economic and Security Challenges Amidst Rising Tensions at ASEAN and East Asia Summits
US Warns Israel Against Expanded Military Operations Amid Rising Tensions in the Middle East
Global Update: UNICEF Reveals Dire Sexual Violence Stats in Africa, NLD Faces Turmoil in Myanmar, and DACA Under Review While Storms and Safety Threats Unfold
Tensions Rise in Middle East as Lebanese Army Arrests Syrian Spies and Israel Intensifies Strikes, Amid U.S. Political Shifts and Nobel Prize Announcements
Tragic Missile Strike in Odesa, Hurricane Milton Threatens Florida, and UK Conservative Leadership Race Heats Up
Saudi Arabia's Strategic Moves: Wage Insurance for Foreign Workers and Strengthening Global Diplomatic Ties Amid Regional Turmoil
Saudi Arabia's Dynamic Shift: From Global Market Access to Cultural Innovation and Biotech Ambitions Under Vision 2030
×